Episode 25

This episode of Stand-up Teardown features hosts Sean Fau and Matthew Ballek reviewing three stand-up specials. They discuss the performances of Adam Carolla, Stephen Rogers, and Trey Kennedy, noting that all three specials happen to be clean comedy acts.

Adam Carolla’s Special

Adam Carolla is introduced as an American comedian, radio personality, actor, and podcaster, known for Loveline and The Man Show. This special is his first clean stand-up attempt, released through Dry Bar Comedy, which is known for clean acts. Sean notes that much of Carolla’s material rehashes content from his podcast, making it feel like a “greatest hits compilation” rather than fresh material for regular listeners. Matthew observes that Carolla’s pacing feels uncomfortable at times, lacking the command of the stage seen in seasoned stand-ups. They attribute this to his background primarily in radio rather than stand-up, suggesting he needs more time to develop his stage presence. Carolla jokes about driving in Malibu and seeing luxury cars versus a Saturn, and his experience doing a clean show for the first time. He also critiques Olympic fencing, suggesting that the outfits should reflect historical swordsmen. A notable moment involves audience interaction where a man is getting a foot rub during the show.

Stephen Rogers’ Special

Stephen Rogers is a comedian who has appeared on The Late Late Show with Stephen Colbert and James Corden, and is a regular at New York’s Comedy Cellar. His special, Half of We, is produced by Nate Bargatze and Brian Regan’s offshoot company. Both hosts are impressed with Rogers’ performance. Sean praises his originality, noting that he doesn’t seem to be imitating other comedians and has a “fully formed” voice. Matthew describes his delivery as “confident but relaxed” with an “enjoyable anxiety.” They highlight his ability to pull jokes from simple observations and his effective use of physicality and facial expressions. Rogers jokes about people giving up and being themselves, the awkwardness of wearing a leather jacket, and people assuming he owns a printer. He also discusses his social anxiety, including hiding from acquaintances in public and his inability to confront Uber drivers.

Trey Kennedy’s Special

Trey Kennedy is a comedian and actor who started on Vine and is known for his clean, family-friendly style, sketches, and podcast Correct Opinions. Sean notes Kennedy’s high energy and performance quality, comparing it to early Dane Cook. However, Matthew feels that the material, particularly about parenting, is “well-trod territory” and lacks new angles, making it feel “fluffy.” They also comment that his style sometimes resembles a “cool pastor at a mega church.” Kennedy discusses the challenges of being a new father and how it affects his marriage. He also shares anecdotes about gender reveal parties and the expectations surrounding them.

Conclusion

Both hosts agree that Stephen Rogers was the best performer of the episode, citing his consistent humor, original delivery, and immediate comedic impact. They commend his ability to deliver laughs from the start without needing a buildup. While they appreciate Adam Carolla’s brand, they feel he still needs more time to develop as a stand-up comedian. Trey Kennedy’s performance, while energetic, was seen as less impactful due to the familiar nature of his material.